Dr Srabani Basu, Associate Professor, Department of Literature and Languages, SRM University AP
What happens when a society teaches half its population that vulnerability is a weakness, tenderness is feminine, and emotional silence is strength?
A little boy falls while playing. His knees are bruised, his eyes fill with tears, and before he can express his pain, an adult intervenes with a familiar instruction: “Don’t cry. Be a man.” Another boy is ridiculed for being sensitive, another is told that he behaves like a girl, and yet another discovers that affection, fear, and tenderness must be carefully concealed if he wishes to earn approval. These seemingly insignificant moments become the earliest lessons in an elaborate social curriculum. Long before boys understand what masculinity means, they begin learning what it supposedly forbids. And somewhere between childhood and adulthood, an extraordinary transformation takes place. The boy who was naturally capable of expressing a complete spectrum of human emotions becomes a man who has learned to censor himself.
What makes this conditioning particularly disturbing is that vulnerability is not inherently feminine, just as strength is not inherently masculine. Both are human capacities. Yet societies have historically organised emotional expression along gendered boundaries, assigning tenderness, dependence, and sensitivity to women while reserving stoicism, aggression, and emotional restraint for men. The irony is remarkable. The very qualities that make human relationships meaningful become liabilities when displayed by men. A boy learns that his emotional legitimacy depends not upon what he experiences but upon how successfully he conceals it.
The philosopher Judith Butler’s concept of gender performativity offers an illuminating perspective on this phenomenon. Gender, in this framework, is not simply something individuals possess. It is continuously reproduced through socially regulated actions, gestures, language, and expectations. Masculinity, therefore, becomes something that must repeatedly be demonstrated, validated, and defended. Sociologist R. W. Connell’s concept of hegemonic masculinity further helps explain how particular ideals of manhood acquire cultural authority, privileging dominance, control, heterosexual conformity, and emotional invulnerability over alternative expressions of masculine identity.
For many boys, masculinity becomes an examination they never consciously enrolled in yet must continue taking throughout their lives. Every tear withheld becomes evidence of toughness. Every fear concealed becomes an assertion of courage. Every emotional need denied becomes another successful performance of manhood. The tragedy is that the performance gradually becomes indistinguishable from the performer. What begins as a strategy for social acceptance eventually becomes an internalised understanding of the self.
This does not mean that all men experience masculinity identically or that emotional restraint is inherently unhealthy. Cultural contexts, family environments, personalities, and individual experiences produce considerable variations. Emotional regulation can be a valuable life skill. However, regulation and suppression are fundamentally different. Regulation involves recognising emotions and choosing how to respond. Suppression often begins by denying oneself permission to acknowledge that those emotions exist.
Consider what happens when a child repeatedly receives the message that sadness is shameful, fear is cowardice, and seeking comfort is weakness. He does not necessarily stop experiencing these emotions. Instead, he learns to disconnect their expression from his public identity. Over time, this may create difficulties in identifying, articulating, and communicating emotional experiences. Psychological research on restrictive masculine norms has associated certain patterns of emotional suppression and reluctance to seek help with poorer mental health outcomes, although individual experiences vary.
Perhaps one of the most consequential outcomes is the narrowing of acceptable emotional expression. Anger, unlike sadness or fear, is often culturally permitted as masculine. Consequently, emotional experiences that might otherwise be expressed through grief, disappointment, uncertainty, or hurt may sometimes emerge as irritability, hostility, or aggression. A man who cannot comfortably say, “I am frightened of losing you,” may instead become controlling. Someone unable to acknowledge humiliation may respond with excessive defensiveness. A person who struggles to admit inadequacy may compensate through relentless competitiveness.
These are possibilities rather than inevitable outcomes, and aggression has many causes beyond gender conditioning. Nevertheless, the pattern deserves attention because emotional suppression does not eliminate emotional experience. It can simply change the language through which that experience becomes visible.
The consequences frequently extend into intimate relationships. Men may be expected to provide emotional security while having been denied opportunities to develop emotional fluency themselves. They are encouraged to be protectors but discouraged from acknowledging their own need for protection. They are expected to understand their partners’ feelings while having learned to distrust their own. This contradiction can create relationships in which affection exists, but emotional communication remains painfully inadequate.
The implications become particularly significant when these boys grow into positions of authority. Leadership does not emerge independently of personal history. Individuals carry their emotional habits, defensive strategies, assumptions, and learned behavioural patterns into professional environments. The boardroom does not magically erase the conditioning of childhood. It frequently provides a more sophisticated stage upon which that conditioning can continue.
Traditional leadership cultures have often celebrated characteristics historically associated with dominant models of masculinity: decisiveness, assertiveness, competitiveness, control, and unwavering confidence. These characteristics can be useful in appropriate contexts. The problem arises when they become the exclusive markers of leadership legitimacy, while empathy, uncertainty, openness, and vulnerability are interpreted as evidence of incompetence.
A leader conditioned never to admit fear may struggle to acknowledge organisational risks. Someone taught that uncertainty signals weakness may present confidence even when the available information is insufficient. A leader who interprets disagreement as a threat to personal authority may discourage dissent rather than encourage critical inquiry. And someone who regards emotional expression as unprofessional may create an organisational culture in which employees conceal distress, avoid difficult conversations, and hesitate to seek support.
The result can be a leadership style organised around maintaining an appearance of invulnerability rather than developing genuine organisational resilience.
There is another paradox here. Organisations increasingly recognise the importance of psychological safety, emotional intelligence, empathy, collaboration, and adaptive leadership. Yet many continue to reward behavioural performances that contradict these aspirations. Leaders are urged to demonstrate empathy while being implicitly penalised for revealing uncertainty. They are encouraged to build trust while operating within cultures that equate authority with emotional distance. They are expected to cultivate authenticity while sustaining carefully constructed images of invincibility.
Perhaps the most damaging consequence is the confusion between vulnerability and incompetence. A leader who says, “I do not know,” is not necessarily demonstrating inadequacy. Such an admission may reflect intellectual honesty and openness to learning. A leader who acknowledges a mistake may be exercising accountability rather than surrendering authority. Similarly, expressing concern for an employee’s well-being does not undermine professional judgement. It recognises that organisations are human systems rather than mechanical arrangements of interchangeable resources.
The challenge, therefore, is not to feminise men or masculinise women. That would merely preserve the very binary responsible for the problem. The challenge is to dismantle the assumption that human capabilities possess gender identities. Empathy does not belong to women. Courage does not belong to men. Vulnerability is not the opposite of strength, and emotional openness is not synonymous with fragility.
This transformation must begin much earlier than leadership development programmes. It begins when a boy is allowed to cry without humiliation, when tenderness is appreciated without ridicule, and when emotional vocabulary becomes as important as academic achievement. It continues when families, educational institutions, and workplaces stop treating emotional expression as a violation of masculine identity.
Leadership development must similarly move beyond teaching behavioural techniques towards examining the unconscious beliefs that shape behaviour. Leaders need opportunities to recognise their defensive patterns, question inherited assumptions about authority, and distinguish emotional maturity from emotional concealment. Psychological safety must become a lived organisational practice rather than a fashionable expression in leadership presentations.
Ultimately, the question is not whether men should become more vulnerable. Men have always been vulnerable because vulnerability is inseparable from being human. The question is whether society will finally permit them to acknowledge what has always been true.
Perhaps the greatest disservice we have done to generations of boys is convincing them that becoming men requires abandoning parts of themselves. And perhaps the most profound transformation in leadership will occur when strength is no longer measured by how successfully individuals conceal their humanity, but by how courageously they embrace it.
After all, what kind of strength requires a human being to pretend that he cannot be hurt?












